 My Math Forum Why wouldn't the horizontal component of the force make yo-yo to move ?

 Physics Physics Forum

October 27th, 2019, 06:14 AM   #1
Newbie

Joined: Aug 2019
From: India

Posts: 23
Thanks: 1

Why wouldn't the horizontal component of the force make yo-yo to move ?

The problem statement is:
A yo-yo rests on a table (see the attachment) and the free end of its string is gently pulled at an angle $\displaystyle \theta$ to the horizontal as shown. What is the critical value of $\displaystyle \theta$ such that the yo-yo remains stationary, even though it is free to roll? (This problem may be solved geometrically if you consider the torques about P, the point of contact with the table).

Now, the thing is that this problem can be solved ( I mean answer can be made to come right) if we assume a few things and those assumptions are my problem.

The proposed solution is: (see the second attachment for reference) The angle between $\displaystyle r$ and $\displaystyle R$ is $\displaystyle \theta$ because of the principle the angle between two lines is the angle between their normals and $\displaystyle r$ is perpendicular to the line of force because it is tangent to that inner circle and $\displaystyle R$ is perpendicular to horizontal line.
Now just equate the torques produced by these forces:
$\displaystyle F~\sin\theta ~r \sin\theta = F~\cos\theta~(R-r\cos\theta)$
$\displaystyle r \sin^2\theta = R~\cos\theta - r~\cos^2 \theta$
$\displaystyle r= R~\cos\theta$
$\displaystyle \theta = \cos^{-1} (r/R)$

(I have included the solution with all possible intricacies only because to save your precious time, I know these things are so easy for you and my intention was not to exhibit anything it was purely for clarity and time saving.)

Now, how can we ever ignore the translational effect of $\displaystyle F~cos\theta$? I mean it would cause the the yo-yo to translate in horizontal direction if there were no friction. And if there were to have a friction then for critical angle our equation would be very simple
$\displaystyle F~\cos\theta + Friction =0$
$\displaystyle \theta = \cos^{-1} (-Friction/F)$.

So why we are not considering it? I mean why are we just assuming that $\displaystyle \Sigma F=0$ and $\displaystyle \Sigma \tau=0$ (I must clarify that some people in US call torque as moment and denote it by M, here moment has been phrased as torque and is represented by tau \tau). What are the reasons for taking those two assumptions?

Thank you. Any help will be much appreciated.
Attached Images Physics.jpg (11.2 KB, 1 views) solution 1.jpg (9.0 KB, 1 views) Solution2.jpg (13.5 KB, 1 views)

Last edited by skipjack; October 27th, 2019 at 09:15 AM. October 27th, 2019, 08:12 AM #2 Math Team   Joined: Jul 2011 From: Texas Posts: 3,101 Thanks: 1677 Reference the diagram ... As shown above, all forces acting on the yoyo (string tension F , weight mg, normal force N, and static friction f) act through point P, the point of contact with the ground, hence the net torque on the yoyo is zero. As you stated, the angle $\theta$ where the yoyo remains in equilibrium is $\theta = \arccos\left(\dfrac{r}{R}\right)$ Reviewing the equilibrium of the translational forces ... $F\cos{\theta} = f$ $N + F\sin{\theta} = mg$ ... and the rotational forces about point C (the center) $F \cdot r - f \cdot R = 0$ $F \cdot r - F\cos{\theta} \cdot R = 0$ $F(r - \cos{\theta} \cdot R) = 0$ $F \ne 0 \implies r = R\cos{\theta} \implies \cos{\theta} = \dfrac{r}{R}$ Thanks from topsquark, romsek and Adesh Mishra October 27th, 2019, 08:38 AM #3 Newbie   Joined: Aug 2019 From: India Posts: 23 Thanks: 1 I have one doubt : the tension force is applied at the inner circle so we should find the effective lever arm from P to that point. But you have made that as if string force is acting on P. I mean that tension force is in contact with the inner circle so I think it would cause a net torque at P. I request you to please clear my doubt October 27th, 2019, 08:53 AM   #4
Math Team

Joined: Jul 2011
From: Texas

Posts: 3,101
Thanks: 1677

Quote:
 Originally Posted by Adesh Mishra I have one doubt : the tension force is applied at the inner circle so we should find the effective lever arm from P to that point. But you have made that as if string force is acting on P. I mean that tension force is in contact with the inner circle so I think it would cause a net torque at P. I request you to please clear my doubt
Consider a door hinged at point H with a string exerting a force outward from the door edge as shown in the "view from above" attached ... would it exert a torque on the door?

Is not the lever arm relative to the hinge zero?
Attached Images door_force.jpg (13.8 KB, 1 views)

Last edited by skeeter; October 27th, 2019 at 09:43 AM. October 27th, 2019, 09:56 AM #5 Newbie   Joined: Aug 2019 From: India Posts: 23 Thanks: 1 Thank you so much for being so clear. Tags component, equilibrium, force, horizontal, make, move, yoyo Thread Tools Show Printable Version Email this Page Display Modes Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode Similar Threads Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post leo255 Calculus 1 December 16th, 2014 08:48 PM limes5 Real Analysis 0 June 27th, 2013 05:18 AM mr calculus Applied Math 1 February 21st, 2013 03:39 PM subwayheaven Algebra 1 January 25th, 2013 10:02 AM

 Contact - Home - Forums - Cryptocurrency Forum - Top      