
Number Theory Number Theory Math Forum 
 LinkBack  Thread Tools  Display Modes 
September 11th, 2012, 05:58 PM  #1 
Senior Member Joined: Jan 2010 Posts: 324 Thanks: 0  Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ...
Proof of: There does not exist a unique x that is an element of the rationals such that x squared equals 3. Would contradiction be the way to do this or trichotomy like how you would for there exists a unique x >0 such that x squared equals 2? 
September 11th, 2012, 06:33 PM  #2 
Senior Member Joined: Jul 2010 From: St. Augustine, FL., U.S.A.'s oldest city Posts: 12,211 Thanks: 520 Math Focus: Calculus/ODEs  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
Personally, I would use reductio ad absurdum (contradiction) for this.

September 11th, 2012, 06:44 PM  #3 
Senior Member Joined: Nov 2011 Posts: 595 Thanks: 16  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
Hi, Ok I have never been very good at this so please don't take this for granted, might be wrong, just an attempts here. So if is rational ,there exists p and q with gcd(p,q)=1 such that implies that . Since 3 is prime can not divide 3, so divides which means there exists an integer a such that which means which is absurd (a is an integer). I guess this shows generally (IF it is correct....) that with p prime is always irrational. 
September 11th, 2012, 07:03 PM  #4 
Senior Member Joined: Jan 2010 Posts: 324 Thanks: 0  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
Mark, elaborate. I would do x squared does not equal three (he hasnt defined square root so i cant use it in the proof). Then do what? 
September 11th, 2012, 08:18 PM  #5 
Senior Member Joined: Nov 2011 Posts: 595 Thanks: 16  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
So is there something wrong in the proof I wrote? Would be nice to at least acknowledge you saw it, especially when people spend a bit of their time to try to help I hope it is not just a problem that "he hasnt defined defined square root" because you can of course simply start the proof saying: Let us assume a rational x=p/q such that so that and then catch back above.... 
September 11th, 2012, 08:20 PM  #6 
Senior Member Joined: Jul 2010 From: St. Augustine, FL., U.S.A.'s oldest city Posts: 12,211 Thanks: 520 Math Focus: Calculus/ODEs  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
I would begin by assuming there is a rational number whose square is 3: where p and q are coprime, i.e., is in lowest terms. This implies: which means must be a multiple of 3, but since p is squared, it must be a multiple of 9, which implies must also be a multiple of 9, and so our assumption that p and q are coprime has been contradicted. 
September 11th, 2012, 08:34 PM  #7  
Senior Member Joined: Nov 2011 Posts: 595 Thanks: 16  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
I think this one also works! Just when you say Quote:
 
September 11th, 2012, 08:46 PM  #8 
Senior Member Joined: Jul 2010 From: St. Augustine, FL., U.S.A.'s oldest city Posts: 12,211 Thanks: 520 Math Focus: Calculus/ODEs  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
Yes, you are right, I meant to type a 3, but typed 9 instead! I'm glad you caught that! 
September 11th, 2012, 09:04 PM  #9 
Senior Member Joined: Nov 2011 Posts: 595 Thanks: 16  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
No problem And both proofs would work the same for any prime number instead of three 
September 11th, 2012, 09:08 PM  #10 
Senior Member Joined: Jul 2010 From: St. Augustine, FL., U.S.A.'s oldest city Posts: 12,211 Thanks: 520 Math Focus: Calculus/ODEs  Re: Proof for there does not exist a unique x that is an ..
Yes, and hopefully we are not as stricken as the followers of Pythagoras... 

Tags 
exist, proof, unique 
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  

Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
unique factorization domain, zero of a polynomial , proof  rayman  Abstract Algebra  2  October 19th, 2012 06:38 AM 
0/0 does not exist?  Dart Plegius  Algebra  4  June 19th, 2012 12:37 PM 
Prove that lim (x > 0) (1/x^2) does not exist  scherz0  Real Analysis  10  October 24th, 2009 01:21 PM 
Does the following limit exist?  BUBLIL  Complex Analysis  1  December 12th, 2008 08:15 AM 
Does this graph exist?  tinatran2  Applied Math  1  May 9th, 2007 08:16 PM 