My Math Forum  

Go Back   My Math Forum > Math Forums > Math

Math General Math Forum - For general math related discussion and news


Thanks Tree3Thanks
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
May 21st, 2017, 01:59 PM   #21
Math Team
 
Joined: Oct 2011
From: Ottawa Ontario, Canada

Posts: 9,768
Thanks: 651

Sigh...I quit.
Denis is offline  
 
May 22nd, 2017, 01:40 AM   #22
Global Moderator
 
Joined: Dec 2006

Posts: 17,491
Thanks: 1315

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abidur Rahman View Post
If you ask a question that considers the hypothetical response of another question, you narrow down the valid responses available to the gatekeeper until he is only allowed to tell the truth.
Any question could be rephrased so that it's not the same question, but has equivalent meaning. More important, though is that actually asking only one question (which must be answered with "yes" or "no") implies that the answer given is the first answer given, and so can be "yes" or "no". Any hypothetical questions considered prior to answering do not give rise to actual answers, so they don't force the answer to the one question asked to be truthful.
skipjack is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 08:43 AM   #23
Newbie
 
Joined: May 2017
From: England

Posts: 13
Thanks: 0

Quote:
Originally Posted by skipjack View Post
Any hypothetical questions considered prior to answering do not give rise to actual answers, so they don't force the answer to the one question asked to be truthful.
I think hypothetical questions can force an answer. Let me try one more time and you can tell me where I go wrong.

To make this simpler I'll label a yes and no from each question with a number like this: yes/01, no/01

Q1) I ask the doorkeeper: is the treasure in door A. If the answer is yes_01 and it's true, then the treasure is in door A otherwise if it's a lie, then the treasure is in door B. If the answer is no_1 and it's true, then the treasure is in door B otherwise if it's a lie, then the treasure is in door A.

A question that considers a hypothetical response would be like this:

Q2) If I asked you Q1 and you say yes_01 would yes_01 be a lie? In this case, if the doorkeeper responds yes_02 and it's true, then yes_01 was a lie which we already said means that the treasure is in door B otherwise if yes_02 is a lie, then yes_01 is true and the treasure is in door A. If the doorkeeper responds no_2 and it's true, then yes_01 is true and the treasure is in door A. However, if the doorkeeper responds no_2 and it's a lie, then yes_01 is a lie, but this would be impossible as the doorkeeper can only lie once. This still doesn't eliminate all the options,so we need to ask a better question.

This will be the best question.

Q3) If I asked you Q2 and you say yes_02 would yes_02 be a lie? If the doorkeeper responds yes_03 and it's true, then yes_02 is a lie which means yes_01 is true and thus the treasure is in door A. However, if the doorkeeper says yes_03 and it's a lie, then yes_02 is the truth which means yes_01 is a lie, but this means that the doorkeeper would lie more than once, so this is impossible. If the doorkeeper instead says no_3 and no_3 is true, then yes_2 is true and thus yes_01 is a lie, so the treasure is in door B. However, if the doorkeeper says no_3 and no_3 is a lie, then yes_2 is a lie but this is impossible as the doorkeeper can not lie more than once.

Therefore, Q3 can give you the right answer. I think this works because a false yes is the same as a true no and a false no is the same as a true yes. So if the question asks whether a yes is false or true, then you obtain the information about the value for no.

Last edited by skipjack; May 23rd, 2017 at 10:43 AM.
Abidur Rahman is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 10:27 AM   #24
Global Moderator
 
Joined: Dec 2006

Posts: 17,491
Thanks: 1315

It doesn't matter that "as the doorkeeper can only lie once" is part of the doorkeeper's thought process, because thinking about a lie doesn't constitute lying, and so doesn't affect whether the answer to your question can be a lie. You must ensure that both "yes" and "no" are valid answers, "yes" meaning (to you) one particular selection and "no" meaning the other selection. The doorkeeper isn't allowed to answer "I don't know" or "I don't understand". You might be able to get round this impasse by allowing a question that is directly self-referential (by referring to its own answer).
skipjack is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 11:33 AM   #25
Newbie
 
Joined: May 2017
From: England

Posts: 13
Thanks: 0

So are you saying that as the question is hypothetical, the no_2 lie would be the first time the doorkeeper lied which means that it would still satisfy the rules of the puzzle?

But wait, if lying and saying no is not a possible answer, then why would the doorkeeper even considering making an impossible statement? Wouldn't it swap to the more valid options if lying and saying no at the same time is invalid or impossible?

How does that work? The doorkeeper is still allowed to lie, but at the same time, lying is not even an answer, i.e. by lying about if you would have lied when you are only allowed to lie once and saying no I wouldn't have lied means that you would have lied, but now you can't lie as that would mean you lied more than once. Does this mean that my logic is incorrect and if so what would happen if, let's say, a computer had to run this as a program?

If I was the doorkeeper, I would think that since this response does not work and doesn't fit into the category of lie, then I would have to say the truth. BTW if there is a way to get round this impasse, please tell me.

Last edited by skipjack; May 23rd, 2017 at 10:31 AM.
Abidur Rahman is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 01:11 PM   #26
Math Team
 
Joined: Oct 2011
From: Ottawa Ontario, Canada

Posts: 9,768
Thanks: 651

Abe, why don't you actually try this out with a friend.

He flips a coin and lies if it's tail, tells truth otherwise.
You of course are not "watching" this coin flip.
Get my drift?

Note: you need to have a friend
Denis is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 01:39 PM   #27
Newbie
 
Joined: May 2017
From: England

Posts: 13
Thanks: 0

Quote:
Originally Posted by Denis View Post

Note: you need to have a friend
Shit, I'm screwed
Abidur Rahman is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 02:38 PM   #28
Math Team
 
agentredlum's Avatar
 
Joined: Jul 2011
From: North America, 42nd parallel

Posts: 3,276
Thanks: 204

"If you lied about the treasure being behind door A , is the treasure behind door B?"

Suppose door A has the treasure , he would have to lie and say no so his response to the second part would have to be a truthful no

Suppose door B has the treasure , he would have to lie and say yes so his response to the second part would have to be a truthful yes.

In this scenario a no response means door A and a yes response means door B

agentredlum is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 02:57 PM   #29
Math Team
 
Joined: Dec 2013
From: Colombia

Posts: 6,854
Thanks: 2228

Math Focus: Mainly analysis and algebra
He doesn't have to answer both parts separately. But you can't tell whether the answer is a comment on the logical relation between the two clauses; or a reply only to the second clause.
v8archie is offline  
May 22nd, 2017, 11:07 PM   #30
Newbie
 
Joined: May 2017
From: England

Posts: 13
Thanks: 0

Quote:
Originally Posted by agentredlum View Post
"If you lied about the treasure being behind door A , is the treasure behind door B?"

Suppose door A has the treasure , he would have to lie and say no so his response to the second part would have to be a truthful no

Suppose door B has the treasure , he would have to lie and say yes so his response to the second part would have to be a truthful yes.

In this scenario a no response means door A and a yes response means door B

Yeah, I think you are right. I'll check this properly later
Abidur Rahman is offline  
Reply

  My Math Forum > Math Forums > Math

Tags
confusing, logic, problem



Thread Tools
Display Modes


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
A REALLY confusing problem! Abidur Rahman New Users 0 May 17th, 2017 11:48 AM
Confusing word problem Bobbyjoe Calculus 4 February 27th, 2017 06:34 AM
neither is neither? confusing logic. pinappleburger Algebra 2 November 3rd, 2013 01:15 AM
Another confusing word problem cherryperry Elementary Math 1 May 29th, 2010 01:29 PM
Confusing problem beatboxbo Calculus 5 October 25th, 2007 12:43 AM





Copyright © 2017 My Math Forum. All rights reserved.