- **Algebra**
(*http://mymathforum.com/algebra/*)

- - **Bags and Balls**
(*http://mymathforum.com/algebra/29163-bags-balls.html*)

Bags and BallsThree bags contain 2 white, 3 black and ; 4 white, 1 black ; 3 white, 7 black balls; respectively. One ball is drawn from one of the bags and found to be black. The probability that it was drawn from the bag mentioned last is: 1)7/10 2)7/11 3)7/15 4)11/15 5)none Please add valid reasons and steps.. |

Re: Bags and BallsIs the bag the black ball is drawn from selected at random? |

Re: Bags and Balls@Greg- Yeah.... |

Re: Bags and BallsWell, if that's the case I get 7/30. Reason: there's a 1/3 chance of selecting the bag with ten balls and a 7/10 chance of drawing a black ball from that bag. 1/3 * 7/10 = 7/30. That's not in the list of choices for a correct answer, though. I'm interpreting the question as asking "what is the probability of selecting a black ball from the bag with ten balls?" |

Re: Bags and BallsI'd go with conditional probability here...Bayes theorem, what have you. |

Re: Bags and BallsThanks, [color=#00BF40]The Chaz[/color].Let P(T|B) be the probability that, given that a black ball is drawn, it came from the bag with ten balls. Let P(B|T) the probability that the ball is black, given that it came from the bag with ten balls and P(B) the overall probability that the ball is black. Using Bayes' Theorem, we have P(T|B) = (P(B|T)P(T))/P(B) = (7/10 * 1/3)/(1/2) = 7/15. |

Re: Bags and BallsBut according to me the answer is none.. The solution would be 'None'. This is because the answer is 7/30. This is derived from the calculation of the conditional probability, the probability that the last bag was chosen and the ball was black in it. This would be 1/3 *7/10. I am still not sure with the solution...:( |

Re: Bags and BallsHmm . . . but it is given the ball is black. |

Re: Bags and BallsQuote:
Think of ALL the ways to get a black ball. THIS is where your thinking/calculation will be appropriate: Black ball in bag 1: 1/3*3/5 Black ball in bag 2: 1/3*1/5 Black ball in bag 3: 1/3*7/10 Add all these up... 1/5 + 1/15 + 7/30. This is the probability of getting ANY black. It's 1/2. What proportion of this (1/2) came from bag 3? (contribution from bag 3)/(probability of any black) (7/30)/(1/2) = 7/15 |

All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:43 AM. |

Copyright © 2019 My Math Forum. All rights reserved.