vector problem in three dimensions First of all, sorry if this isn't the right place to post this. Four points A, B,C and D have coordinates (0, 1, 2), (1, 3, 2), (4, 3, 4) and (5, 1, 2) respectively. Find the position vectors of a. The midpoint E of AC b. The point F on BC such that BF/FD = 1/3 Use your answers to draw a sketch showing the relative positions of A, B, C and D I had no difficulty solving a. and b.: both E and F have position vectors (2i, 2j, k) This confuses as with respect to the last exercise, though. If E and F have the same position vectors, they should be the same point. Since E lies on AC and F on BC, shouldn’t A, B and C lie on the same line? However, vector AC = 4i + 2j + 6k and vector BC = 3i + 2k: they are not multiples, so A, B and C are not collinear. I’m new to the study of vectors in three dimensions so there’s probably a noob mistake I’m making somewhere. What am I missing? 
Re: vector problem in three dimensions You are in the correct forum. How did you calculate the answers for questions a and b? 
Re: vector problem in three dimensions Quote:

Re: vector problem in three dimensions Quote:
Quote:
Thanks for your time btw. 
Re: vector problem in three dimensions Can you post your working for part b? 
Re: vector problem in three dimensions Quote:
x = 1 + 3t y = 3 z = 2 + 2t Clearly (2,2,1) is not on that line. Use (1+3t,3,2+3t) as F. Calculate the distances from F to B and F to D. Set the ratio equal to 1/3 and solve for t. Then plug it into the equation for BC to find the point. I think you get a quadratic equation but it is ugly. 
Re: vector problem in three dimensions hmm i'll post my work then. however the answer given in the textbook IS 2i + 2j + k and I remember coming to that exact conclusion very convincingly. That could hardly be a coincidence, but I'll be back with my work anyway. Also, what is 't' in your equation of BC? Once again, thanks to both of you for helping out 
Re: vector problem in three dimensions Quote:
If you got point F in part b from: then you are assuming that F lies on BD not BC. That is why I think the problem might be a misprint. 
Re: vector problem in three dimensions Alright so here’s my work on b. : We have 3BF = FD, f = BF + b And since we know b, all we need is BF to find f position vector of F BF + FD = BD => 4BF = d – b = 4i – 4j – 4k => BF = i – j – k => f = (1+1)i + (31)j + (21)k = 2i + 2j + k Now I’m aware that my error lies in assuming the vector BF equals onethird of vector FD, as this proportion only applies to the lengths of the vectors and not the vectors themselves. It WOULD mean the same thing, however, if F lies on BD and not BC, as abovementioned but which I have only just understood. So I'm starting to think this must just be a typo. 
All times are GMT 8. The time now is 12:27 PM. 
Copyright © 2019 My Math Forum. All rights reserved.