My Math Forum  

Go Back   My Math Forum > Math Forums > Academic Guidance

Academic Guidance Academic Guidance - Academic guidance for those pursuing a college degree... what college? Grad school? PhD help?

LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
May 26th, 2016, 01:20 AM   #1
Joined: Apr 2013

Posts: 36
Thanks: 0

How to replying to comments of referee when doing revision


I am a Ph.D. student and I have submitted my first paper to a mathematical journal. The referees proposed a major revision and resubmit a revised version. They gave a detailed list of amendments to make. Unfortunately, I cannot understand one of the comments made because it refers to part of texts which I cannot find. Can someone suggest ideas to reply very politely to the referee to ask what he means? I went through the whole paper again, but I cannot understand which part he's referring to.


Last edited by skipjack; May 26th, 2016 at 01:54 AM.
natt010 is offline  
May 26th, 2016, 02:06 AM   #2
Global Moderator
Joined: Dec 2006

Posts: 18,052
Thanks: 1395

Is it possible for you to ask for your supervisor's opinion first?
skipjack is offline  
May 26th, 2016, 02:33 AM   #3
Joined: Apr 2013

Posts: 36
Thanks: 0

Hi, yes I did, he suggested first to try my best to do some form of amendment and if I don't have a clue to ask for further clarification. But i am not sure how to write it politely as I don't want to risk paper not getting published because of this.
natt010 is offline  
May 26th, 2016, 03:18 AM   #4
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2016
From: Australia

Posts: 1,353
Thanks: 464

Math Focus: Yet to find out.
Just say it like it is. If the publisher is not going to publish your paper because you didn't understand what needs to be amended, then it's likely that making your interaction with him/her more polite won't help (much).

The point is, just state what was not understood, and state it clearly such that there is no ambiguity in your question. This will hopefully result in the publisher replying with the answer you seek, and you not having to inquire further.
Joppy is offline  

  My Math Forum > Math Forums > Academic Guidance

comments, referee, replying, revision

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Exam revision MichaelAlex Number Theory 5 September 10th, 2013 04:09 AM
Latex comments soroban New Users 3 April 2nd, 2012 06:14 AM
proof-read / give comments on analysis solutions? watson Real Analysis 1 January 10th, 2012 05:48 PM
Proof-read / give comments on algebra solutions? watson Abstract Algebra 4 January 5th, 2012 10:33 AM

Copyright © 2017 My Math Forum. All rights reserved.